I'd go with definition A, for the most part, hearing the disturbing number of rabid zenophobes who seem determined that the unwashed masses from "över thar" have targeted their castle and have therefore stocked up for WW III, IV & V always concern me, I hear Bangos and my cheeks clench ;^) Makes be feel more secure to be across the ocean from those types.
Skillsets to handle a situation you find yourself in seem prudent and interesting to me, and there's always the possibility that you'll break down or be stuck somewhere in the wilderness and need to get by until you're rescued or get out, at the risk of sounding judgemental, the other crowd never seem quite right in the head to me, anyone who can legitimise to themselves, if not anyone else, that stocking up with automatic weapons and enough ammo to shoot everyone they see for the next 10-20 years is paranoid, and a danger to society and all their neighbours.
Case in point, what I have on order from Cs (and hope to get ONE day) is one of the triple packs of Bushman seconds and a SF shovel, handy, versatile things that can be used in "regular" camping trips, and can extend to other things if the situation gets worse (I don't like killing anything, but hunting for food if required is something that I'm prepared to do, and the Bushmans would be handy for that).
Some of the stories/cases on a survival site I've looked at are interesting, and point out that survival incidents are common, real world things, you don't need any zombie hordes to qualify for a survival incident.
http://equipped.org/srvstoriestoc.htm Other good sites on teh subject are these
http://www.m4040.com/Survival/Survival.htm and
http://www.the-ultralig...ness-survival-guide.html Another viewpoint that always seemed sound to me was that which was described in Robert A Heinland's Tunnel in the Sky, Heinland was writing in the duck and cover days and people were panicing like they are now, the basic story line was that the kids (in the future) were doing survival training, but the advice that the boy was being given by his teacher and sister was valid on how to survive in dangerous situations, such as the Zombie Horde Defenders are always talking about.
NB: You may want to suggest to your relative that he/she read up more on the 2012 story, IF it's accurate, it's more of an apocalyptic scenario, stocking up to defend the castle doesn't make sense if you get wiped off the face of the earth, along with everyone else.
NB: Yeah, I know that the views expressed here will make ME a headcase in many people's eyes, but I can live with that.
FWIW
Neale